https://gilbertdoctorow.substack.com/p/back-to-commentary-on-the-war
Back to commentary on the war
Published by gilbertdoctorow
Gilbert Doctorow's latest book, "War Diaries. The Russia-Ukraine War, 2022-2023" is a unique contribution to literature on the war thanks to the author's reports on the Russian home front written during his periodic visits to St Petersburg at a time when Russia no longer issued visas and nearly all Western journalists had left the country. Doctorow's two-volume "Memoirs of a Russianist" published in 2020 also constitutes a category of its own, consisting largely of diary entries rather than reminiscences written decades later.. Volume 2 focuses on the community of 50,000 expatriate managers working and living in Moscow during the 1990s, about which none of his peers has yet to write. Gilbert Doctorow is a professional Russia watcher and actor in Russian affairs going back to 1965. He is a magna cum laude graduate of Harvard College (1967), a past Fulbright scholar, and holder of a Ph.D. with honors in history from Columbia University (1975). After completing his studies, Mr. Doctorow pursued a business career focused on the USSR and Eastern Europe. For twenty-five years he worked for US and European multinationals in marketing and general management with regional responsibility. From 1998-2002, Doctorow served as the Chairman of the Russian Booker Literary Prize in Moscow. During the 2010-2011 academic year, he was a Visiting scholar of the Harriman Institute, Columbia University. Mr. Doctorow is a long-time resident of Brussels. View all posts by gilbertdoctorow
In full agreement with the commentary.
If things are as they appear to be, Putin is the 21st century Nicholas 1st, and dangerously lucky to not become a Nicholas II.
Peter the Great looks a long way away for him now. Achieving the publically stated goals of the Special Military operation and additionally cutting of Ukraine from the Black Sea could maybe have bestowed upon him this comparison, but this looks to a pipedream.
Were the scale of military losses to correspond to 1 Ukrainian for 1 Russian then Putin is the worst, most callous Russian leader in history. Losses corresponding to something around 1.5 million Ukrainians to say 100000 to 200000 Russians upgrades the victory to somewhat above a pyrrhic one , in my opinion, although more of a moral victory given how unharmed the west is from the war.
Aleksander Lukashenko is the one man who can be pleased with his performance in the SMO thus far.
I would query about the debate on Ukrainians being separate from Russians. On the contrary the core thesis Putin put forth in his historical essay is playing out true- Ukraine as a western created anti-Russia is playing out accurately. An “anti-Russia” is not a unique, separate nation as far as I am concerned. Poland may be anti-Russian, but its culture and history and entire national identity is not as some anti-Russia. Everybody is aware what a Pole is and what a Ukrainian is, this is not the case at all with a Russian and Ukrainian. One of the successes of despicable western propaganda has been in making gullible western audiences blind to just how many Ukrainians live in or have close family in Russia or develop the basic cognition in computing Ukrainian and Russian surnames. If they did then the Banderites would have less western public support
LikeLike