Is Russian acceptance of Ukraine joining NATO inconceivable?

My latest essay entitled “New Confusion on Washington’s Intentions” has stirred up controversy. There were numerous comments on both of my websites and also direct emails to me on the subject.  Among the remarks was the following, which surely invites a delving deeper into the matter:

“It is inconceivable that the Kremlin would agree to Ukraine in NATO under any feasible circumstance.”

As I stated in my essay, the Russian position has been set out very clearly on numerous occasions:  Ukraine must be restored to the neutral status that was enshrined in its constitution when it became an independent state following the break-up of the Soviet Union. Per President Putin, there must be no foreign troops or military installations on Ukrainian soil.

However, this position from the first days of the Special Military Operation has not taken into account the very important changes in Europe’s intentions for its defense ever since President Trump put in doubt the readiness of the U.S.A. to come to its defense under the terms of NATO’s Article 5. That was put in doubt already in his first term when he made American military aid contingent on the Member States raising their military expenditures to specific percentages of their GDP.  Then at the very start of Trump’s second term there was his readiness to go to war against the NATO member state Denmark over possession of Greenland. That made a mockery of the whole concept of the Alliance.  And finally, there was Trump’s cut-off of U.S. supplied military hardware to Ukraine free of charge: it would continue only if the Europeans placed orders and paid for such shipments out of their own pockets, and it would be limited by the depleted American arsenals due to the Iran war.

The net result of all of these words and actions by Donald Trump was to prompt a constellation of leading European states, all members of the Coalition of the Willing hardline backers of Ukraine to enter into an informal defense alliance outside of NATO.  And while my peers in Alternative Media daily celebrate the death of NATO (prematurely in the Mark Twain sense), none seem to be paying attention to the parallel development of what is becoming a formidable fighting force in conventional warfare terms that is totally outside U.S. control.  These are the Europe 5 (France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the U.K.) that intend to represent the Continent at the next round of Russia-Ukraine-USA talks, together with representatives of the European Institutions (Commission and Council).  You will find detailed articles on what their cooperative remilitarization means in practice on the pages of The Financial Times, Bloomberg and other Mainstream news purveyors.

Put in this new context, it might well appear to the Kremlin that Ukraine in a U.S.-led NATO is preferable to Ukraine linked to the European hotheads who foment war fever to stay in power.  This is all the more so if the NATO that emerges from the revision of European security architecture overseen by Trump and Putin is de-fanged, meaning that it pulls back men and materiel from their present forward positions, directly threatening Russia, to their boundaries of 1997, i.e., before the NATO expansion that began in the second term of Bill Clinton

©Gilbert Doctorow, 2026

Donald Trump: the Russians have won the war!

No, dear colleagues, Donald Trump did not say this today, although he is certainly capable of such brutal frankness. Nonetheless, the reality of Russian victory is expressed at the tripartite talks ongoing in Abu Dhabi by the structure of the talks as Russian state television this evening explained to its audience: the territorial issue has been moved to stage two, while the present stage one is all about ensuring the security of BOTH sides in the conflict after conclusion of a peace treaty by revising the security architecture of Europe. And this is being done while the Europeans, who arrived in the capital of the United Arab Emirates uninvited, are excluded from the talks at Russian insistence and are sitting in their hotel rooms cursing the whole American led process.

This is a sea change in American foreign policy which neither Mainstream nor Alt Media seem capable of grasping.

Why, indeed, should the warmongers from Brussels, Paris, Berlin and London be sitting at the table and spoiling the proceedings by their vehement objections to any overall reconciliation with Russia? After all, NATO is the United States, with all other member states just hangers-on.  And if a revision of the security architecture implies changes to or the irrelevancy of NATO, so be it.

    *****

Russian reporting on the talks in Abu Dhabi said nothing about the content of the 5 hours that the sides spent together because all the principals to the talks were mum. But they did tell us who was sitting at the table for all three sides, and that by itself was quite revealing.

Vladimir Medinsky remains the head of the Russian delegation and chief negotiator. Historian of Russia with many books for the patriotic education of Russian youth to his credit, a native “Ukrainian” by birthplace, and now an experienced team leader, Medinsky’s opening remarks pointed to the enlarged Russian delegation which now has several high military officers with knowledge bearing on various dimensions of the talks. Most importantly, at his side was Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sergei Ryabkov. This is the same Ryabkov who was the lead speaker yesterday at the on line Round Table in Vienna yesterday dedicated to the question of the “militarization of Europe: what comes next?”, the speaker who said flatly that if war with Europe should break out “it will be brief,” meaning nuclear. More to the point, this is the same Ryabkov who in December 2021 presented to Washington and to NATO the Russian ultimatum calling for NATO forces to move back to where they were stationed in 1994, before the NATO expansion to the East that should never have taken place. And it was he who said: “if you do not move back, we will move you back!”

As we learned from Yevgeny Popov, Russia’s senior journalist in Abu Dhabi speaking on the 8 o’clock Vesti news, the Ukrainian delegation is headed by Rustem Umerov. His biography in Wikipedia has a couple of paragraph worth citing here to better understand what opportunities his heading the delegation may represent:

Quote

Rustem Enverovych Umerov (Ukrainian: Рустем Енверович Умєров; Crimean Tatar: Rüstem Enver oğlu Ümerov; born 19 April 1982) is a Ukrainian politician, businessman, investor, philanthropist and has served as the head of the Foreign Intelligence Service of Ukraine since 3 August 2026. Previously, he served as the Minister of Defence of Ukraine from 2023 to 2025 and as the Secretary of the National Security and Defence Council from 18 July 2025 to 3 August 2026. He is also a member of the Headquarters of the Supreme Commander-in-Chief.

While attending high school, Umerov participated in the Future Leaders Exchange program funded by the U.S. Department of State. As an exchange student, he lived in a host family and attended an American school for one academic year. Umerov received a bachelor’s degree in economics and a master’s degree in finance from the National Academy of Management.

In 2013, with his brother Aslan Ömer Qırımlı [uk], Umerov founded the investment company ASTEM and its ASTEM Foundation. ASTEM manages investments in the fields of telecommunication, information technology, and infrastructure, mainly communication towers and fiber-optic networks.

The foundation funded Stanford University‘s Ukrainian Emerging Leaders program.”

I think the point is obvious:  Umerov is a very sophisticated fellow. He is not your average thug in the Zelensky entourage. His warm feelings for the USA may make him more open to the complex solutions to the conflict with Russia that Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff have come to discuss.

I close this brief introduction to the talks by noting, per the Russian state television report, that the working language of the talks appears to be Russian.

All of the foregoing is not to suggest that the path ahead will be smooth or that it will end in success. But there definitely is promise in the fact that conceptually it is way above anything that the USA has contemplated since the fall of the USSR.

©Gilbert Doctorow, 2026

Steve Rosenberg, ace reporter in Moscow: far better than any of my peers in Alt Media, far better than his own employers at the BBC

In recent essays, I have mentioned a couple of times the podcasts that BBC Moscow senior journalist Steve Rosenberg has been putting out daily. The main mission he achieves is to provide a comprehensive daily overview of the Russian print media.  Note: he does not touch the electronic media, which is much more state controlled and less nuanced than the newspapers and periodicals.

But that is only the overriding theme of his podcasts. The content varies widely, day by day, according to what he finds especially worth reporting on, as we see in today’s podcast:

. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJvbFdaXzSM

I particularly recommend to the Community his street interviews of average Muscovites on their feelings about Donald Trump after the midterm elections.  This is a level of journalism that no one in Western media is capable of doing or seems to have an interest in doing. And it is invaluable.  

Yes, it is just a sampling, not a statistically founded report.  But it is done with great skill and intelligence.

I wish to emphasize that these podcasts by Rosenberg run directly counter to the anti-Russian propaganda that his employer, the BBC, puts on air 24/24 and 7/7.  How they reconcile what he is doing with what they are doing is beyond understanding. As for him, I imagine that Rosenberg is very glad to have to his BBC job, which gives him unequaled access to Russians, at the top, on the street and wherever he wishes to go.

I would say that Rosenberg is doing the same kind of sound reporting that you will find regularly in The Financial Times, where the editorial position is deeply anti-Russian but many of the journalists are…professional journalists with their own agenda of investigating and writing about very important developments in and around Russia and Ukraine, such as today’s reporting on the Russian equivalent to Starlink that is now being  put in space. This is a factual report which was immediately posted on Russian news websites in extensive translation.

Copyright Gilbert Doctorow, 2026

Postscript: Note that this podcast by Steve Rosenberg has been viewed by 500,000 in the first day following its uploading onto the internet. This rivals if it does not exceed the audience of his employer, the BBC.